Shining fish – a bright-spot analysis of local management and the sustainability of recreational fisheries

This project will use a so called “bright spot” analysis to identify and explore which social and ecological fishery characteristics are associated with proactive, coordinated, and sustainable fisheries management in Sweden.

Details

  • Period: to
  • Budget: 5,974,627 SEK
  • Funder: Formas
  • Type of funding: Project grant - career grant for early-career researchers, career age 0–3 years

Description

Fishing is a popular leisure activity worldwide. In Sweden alone, approximately 1.7 million adults fish annually and the economic turnover is around SEK 14 billion per year. In addition, recreational fishing is an important part of nature-based tourism, which supports small and medium-sized businesses, mainly in rural areas. Recreational fishing can also put a lot of pressure on fish stocks and catches of certain fish species can locally even be higher than in commercial fishing. Management that protects and preserves viable fish stocks in the long term is therefore a necessary condition for recreational fishing to continue to be an important part of outdoor life, the economy and rural development.

Local management is often presented as an alternative that promotes sustainable use of natural resources, but researchers point out that knowledge is still very limited. In Europe, recreational fishing in inland waters is largely managed locally by thousands of organizations consisting of private fishing water owners. These organizations control management relatively independently of both authorities and academia, and thus have a great influence on the development these important resources and fish stocks in particular. Despite the large number of organizations and their great influence, few have studied these organizations and their management. The purpose of this project is to evaluate the role that local management plays in the sustainable development of recreational fishing to understand what factors drive successful and proactive management.

Bridging these knowledge gaps is particularly important in the context of how the management of watersheds and even individual waterbodies is divided among organizations (Fig.1). These aquatic systems are connected regardless of the management decisions made at the local scale. Thus, both the positive and negative impacts of these decisions can lead to spillover effects across unit boundaries. These could be readily visible in the case of migratory species such as salmon and eel, or more subtle as climate and habitat change shift species distributions over time. Regulations intended to shape robust and resilient fish stocks with desirable characteristics for anglers could be nullified by a lack of coordination or enhanced by collaboration among local management organizations.

This project will use a so called “bright spot” analysis to identify and explore which social and ecological fishery characteristics are associated with proactive, coordinated, and sustainable fisheries management. Together with my home and host institutions I will establish a network of stakeholders and experts to identify key management units and watersheds for detailed investigation. Social (e.g., user and stakeholder engagement, management tools in place, promotion of best practices and stewardship) and ecological (e.g., species presence-absence, relative biomass, and habitat connectivity) attributes will be used to evaluate management success in these key units. Expert surveys and interviews will then be used to investigate the social and institutional characteristics that contributed to management quality.

The research results will shed light on questions such as whether and, if so, why some organizations manage recreational fishing in a more sustainable way than others, and how organizations cooperate and coordinate management activities. Based on the research results and a workshop for stakeholders, the project will develop recommendations for future local management of recreational fishing. The project will therefore contribute to the maintenance of viable fish stocks and societal values from lakes, streams, rivers and streams.

Project members

Project leader: Samuel Blyth
Co-investigators: Christian Skov (DTU), Göran Sundblad (Sportfiskarna), Patrik Bohman (SLU), Peter Tibbin (LNU)