Danyang Cui: A Design Approach for Ferrite-Based Spoke-Type Motors for Electric Vehicles: Validation and Life Cycle Assessment

Date
Location
10134 Polhemsalen, Lägerhyddsvägen 1, Uppsala
Type
Thesis defence
Thesis author
Danyang Cui
External reviewer
Pia Lindh
Supervisors
Boel Ekergård, Lena Max, Cecilia Boström
Research subject
Engineering Science with specialization in Science of Electricity
Publication
https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-598306

Abstract

Permanent magnet synchronous motors are widely used in electric vehicle traction because of their high efficiency and power density. Most high-performance designs use neodymium-iron-boron (NdFeB) magnets, which contain rare-earth elements. Ferrite magnets offer a rare-earth-free alternative, and their lower magnetic performance needs to be compensated for through motor design.

This thesis investigates ferrite-based spoke-type motors, focusing on technical feasibility, traction performance, and life cycle environmental performance. A review and benchmarking study identifies traction requirements and design challenges.

A segmented spoke-type motor is developed using rectangular Y40 ferrite magnets, non-magnetic structural components, and a carbon-fiber retaining sleeve. Electromagnetic, demagnetization, and mechanical finite-element analyses are combined with prototype fabrication and no-load validation. Peak torque and power densities reach 21.24 Nm/L and 18.18 kW/L, comparable to commercial reference levels. The design reduces shaft-side leakage flux to nearly zero. Under severe low-temperature conditions, demagnetization causes a simulated torque reduction of approximately 14.7%. Measured air-gap flux density and no-load back electromotive force agree with finite-element results.

The design method from the prototype study is then applied to a separate ferrite-based motor for comparison with a production-based NdFeB reference motor. A surrogate-assisted functional-equivalence framework seeks to match their torque envelopes while minimizing changes to other e-drive components, providing a basis for life-cycle comparison. The selected ferrite design requires a longer active length and higher DC bus voltage than the reference motor. Changes in material composition and driving-cycle electricity consumption are included in a cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment. The ferrite motor has a higher manufacturing-stage climate change impact because lower magnet-related impact does not offset increased use of electrical steel, copper, aluminum, ferrite, and structural materials. However, it consumes less electricity over WLTC. The life cycle comparison therefore depends on electricity carbon intensity, with a break-even value of approximately 60 g CO2-eq/kWh under the conditions and assumptions of this study.

The results demonstrate the technical feasibility of ferrite-based traction motors. Their technical and environmental performance depends on the redesign needed to meet comparable traction requirements. The thesis combines electromagnetic design, functional equivalence, and life cycle assessment to evaluate ferrite-based alternatives to NdFeB traction motors.