Mayya Shmidt: Against The Current: The Emergence of Nonprofit Sharing Field in Sweden
- Datum
- Plats
- University Main Building, Room X, Biskopsgatan 3, Uppsala
- Typ
- Disputation
- Respondent
- Mayya Shmidt
- Opponent
- Ivana Pais
- Handledare
- Reza Azarian, Fredrik Movitz
- Forskningsämne
- Sociologi
- Publikation
- https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-597008
Abstract
How does a field emerge when the organisations trying to build it depend on the very institutions they seek to challenge? Drawing on a qualitative multiple-case study of nonprofit sharing organisations in Sweden, this dissertation explores how initiatives committed to access-based and environmentally oriented alternatives to market exchange sustain themselves despite dependence on external actors operating according to hostile logics. Theoretically, it combines Strategic Action Field theory and the Institutional Logics perspective to conceptualise field emergence as a process of managing institutional pluralism. The dissertation examines: (1) how nonprofit sharing organisations construct a collective identity and field boundaries; (2) how relationships with external actors shape the structure and legitimacy of the emerging field; and (3) how organisations navigate multiple institutional logics while sustaining both autonomy and organisational viability. The findings show that organisations construct field coherence through developing a common cultural-cognitive frame, in which sharing was articulated as a moral and organizational alternative to dominant market arrangements. At the same time, this emerging order remains embedded in its broader environment, particularly relying on relationships with municipalities for critical resources, legitimacy, and infrastructure. This produces a condition of mutual but asymmetrical dependence and gives rise to an autonomy-dependence paradox: organisations must secure external support without compromising their civic identity. To manage this tension, actors engage in strategic action by selectively mobilising competing institutional logics through mechanisms such as selective coupling, decoupling, and isolation. Enabled by the porosity of the emerging field, these practices allow organisations to make their activities simultaneously meaningful internally and legitimate externally. Field emergence thus proceeds through the strategic management of institutional plurality rather than through the stabilisation of a single dominant logic.
Rather than viewing institutional pluralism primarily as a source of fragmentation, the dissertation shows how competing institutional demands can provide the very conditions through which an emerging field is constructed and sustained. It contributes to institutional theory by showing how organisational fields emerge and sustain collective coherence through the interplay of strategic action and institutional constraint, and by demonstrating how field porosity creates opportunities for agency while simultaneously reproducing relations of dependence and power.