Xin Mao: Human Rights Duties: Beyond State and Individual

Datum
Plats
Sal IV, Universitetshuset, Biskopsgatan 3, Uppsala
Typ
Disputation
Respondent
Xin Mao
Opponent
Gotlind Ulshöfer
Handledare
Elena Namli
Forskningsämne
Etik
Publikation
https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-597350

Abstract

The current thesis sets out to examine and develop understandings of human rights duties. Through critically investigate different elements of the widely accepted understanding of human rights duties: individual rights claims, states as the primary human rights duty bearers, and international sanctions of states in human rights interventions, the author reconstructs a common structure underlying classic views on human rights duties-individual claims versus states' correlative duties-which is referred to as the Primary Structure. After analysing the Primary Structure, the author turns to scholarly discussions that challenge the limitations of the Primary Structure, namely, critique of its normative individualism, endeavors to include positive individual duties whose significance it often dismisses, and postcolonial critique of state centric paradigm in the current international human rights norms based upon such structure. 

With such challenges in mind, the current thesis affirms the importance of exploring alternative normative resources to understand human rights duties beyond state and individual, especially from global south traditions which often lay greater emphasis on inter-personal relations and communal livings. The author hence turns to discussions of human rights in contemporary reinterpretations of Confucianism, which is argued to be an enriching dialogue partner to human rights. 

The thesis further maintains that Confucian perspective on human rights duties is set against a continuum between the moral person, families, communities and states, instead of a confrontation between the state and the individual. Such duties are primarily moral, which can complement the legal political aspects of human rights duties in the Primary Structure. Such duties are community based and have features of mutuality and reciprocity in our shared flourishing. 

The thesis finally argues that, Confucian way of understanding duties can contribute to a meaning of pre-emptive duties to human rights, which not only refrain us from harming, or demand us to assist in urgent situations, but also emphasizes long term moral cultivations and community building, that help prevent potential rights violations and promote concrete enjoyments of rights.