Preventive debt counselling hindered by lack of resources - and ethical dilemmas

Calculator

Preventive efforts are not always easy to implement in practice.

Half a million Swedes were indebted to or in debt restructuring with the Swedish Enforcement Authority in 2024. Can more work be done with preventive debt counselling? A new study explores debt counsellors’ perspective.

William Bulow O'Nils

William Bülow O'Nils is senior lecturer of bioethics.

Swedish municipalities are responsible for offering budget and debt counselling to residents struggling with debt, and counsellors are bound by confidentiality. A June 2025 change to the Swedish Social Services Act was intended to enable more preventive and outreach work. But, as a recent study published in Socialvetenskaplig Tidskrift shows, preventive efforts are not always easy to implement in practice.

"This group is in great need of support. Their lives are often characterised by multiple social problems. Unemployment, low well-being and mental illness to name a few," says William Bülow O’Nils, senior lecturer at the Centre for Research & Bioethics at Uppsala University.

According to William Bülow O’Nils and his co-authors Anna Angelin and Mikael Lundholm, debt counsellors’ conditions for working preventively are limited partly by a lack of resources, and partly by the fact that their target group is difficult to reach.

But there are also ethical considerations that affect which preventive measures and individual-oriented interventions are considered acceptable. For example, the risk of causing harm and respecting individuals’ integrity and autonomy. Preventive interventions can also be perceived as intrusive or controlling.

"Contact with social services can have negative connotations and is sometimes misunderstood. Despite good intentions, preventive measures can create anxiety, fear and feelings of shame in the individual. Especially in families with children," says William Bülow O'Nils.

The ethical dilemmas associated with preventive outreach will remain, regardless of whether activities are adequately resourced. The authors stress the importance of adapting preventive work to the specific context of each area of social work. Although there may be considerable political ambition, a one-size-fits-all approach might ultimately be counterproductive.

First author Mikael Lundholm at University of Gothenburg, featured in the journal’s recently launched podcast series on 2 June 2026 to talk about the article.

By Anna Holm Bodin

Mikael Lundholm, Anna Angelin & William Bülow O’Nils, Gräsrotsbyråkraten och denmotvillige brukaren: Erfarenheter från en tidig insats med förebyggande skuldrådgivning, Socialvetenskaplig tidskrift, vol 32, nr 3-4 (2025), s. 396-418, DOI: 10.64098/SVT.2025.32.54869

The latest news from the Centre for Research Ethics & Bioethics