Review on academic career paths

A review has proposed that the University should change promotion to professor from a right as it is currently to a possibility. Photo: Anders Berndt, Uppsala University.
A review of strategic talent attraction at Uppsala University has proposed a raft of changes that could affect future recruitments, career pathways and promotion processes.
The investigator Sven Stafström, professor emeritus at Linköping University and member of the Uppsala University Board, analysed the contribution that our University’s current system is making to the goal of being a world-class research and education university, and has made a number of recommendations.
What is proposed in the report?
The report concludes with some recommendations. They include that the University should make promotion from senior lecturer to professor a possibility, rather than a right as it is currently.
Senior lecturers at Uppsala University have the right to apply for promotion to professor and, provided that they have the requisite professorial qualifications after peer review, they must be promoted.
The report recommends that the University add in a process that looks at the areas in which it is strategically interesting for the University to promote senior lecturers to professor. Thus, it would be possible to say no to a promotion application, even if the person in question does have the requisite qualifications.
What else is proposed in the report?
One proposal is that the number of associate senior lecturers (ASL) should increase, as this form of employment is seen as an effective way to recruit and develop future leaders of research. In addition, stricter requirements for promotion from ASL to senior lecturer are proposed.
The investigator would also like to see more strategic planning of recruitments and promotions through clearer talent attraction plans at the department and faculty levels. These plans would then be used to identify future needs for associate senior lecturers, senior lecturers and professors, but also to address questions around retirements, gender equality and career development.
The investigator also proposes that the University should consider specific career pathways for particularly successful young researchers, with the possibility of fast-tracking their qualifications to attain professorial level. The University should also strive to reduce the processing time for employment matters, and to communicate the strategy for talent attraction more clearly.
Are any changes to the requirements for promotion proposed?
Yes. The review highlights that leadership, research environment development, external funding and the ability to contribute to the long-term development of the University should be important factors when assessing a person for promotion to professor – in addition to scholarly excellence.
Furthermore, the review proposes that when assessing an application for promotion from ASL to senior lecturer, more emphasis should be placed on research quality, independence, scholarly progress and future research plans.
Why was the review carried out?
In the operational plan, the University Board tasked the Vice-Chancellor with drawing up a plan for how the University can increase its scholarly impact. This task has resulted in two tracks of review and action: scholarly publishing and strategic talent attraction.
In April 2025, the Vice-Chancellor decided on a plan for this work and part of it is investigating whether strategic talent attraction can be strengthened. You can read more about that plan via the links in the fact box below.
The task was to investigate how the University’s academic career pathways are contributing to its talent attraction and scholarly quality in the long term. Particular emphasis was placed on the career pathway from associate senior lecturer to senior lecturer and on to professor. Researchers and teaching staff are of course central to a university, and thus questions about talent attraction and career pathways are also central if we aim to be a world-leading university in research and education.
Or as the investigator puts it in the afterword to the report: “Talent attraction is perhaps the most important fundamental factor for the continued success of the University."
Are these proposed changes unique in the higher education world?
No. Several higher education institutions in Sweden already have similar strategies. The investigator has looked closely at a number of different higher education institutions. At Lund University and Chalmers University of Technology, for example, promotion to professor is more clearly tied to the needs of the organisation than at Uppsala University. Karolinska Institutet has no promotion pathway at all from senior lecturer to professor. There, all professorships are appointed in competition, and a talent attraction group decides which professor positions are to be advertised.
When it comes to associate senior lecturers, Lund University, Karolinska Institutet and Chalmers all use this form of employment as an important tool for recruiting young researchers, even if their models differ.
And internationally?
Internationally, too, there are clear career pathway systems, the report concludes. The University of Copenhagen and the University of Groningen have tenure track programmes, where successful researchers can advance from early career positions to professor through structured qualification programmes with regular follow-ups.
What happens next?
The report is a first step in the process of investigating whether there are measures that should be implemented to strengthen the University’s supply of skilled researchers and teachers. No decisions have been made yet. The report contains recommendations, but they are just that: recommendations. The report and its proposals will now be discussed at the University.
The report will be sent out for internal consultation after the 2026 summer holiday period. It was submitted to the Vice-Chancellor already in March, but since there have been some other major internal consultations during the spring, it was deemed better to wait before sending out this report for internal consultation.
Anders Berndt
Facts
The report "Utredning av strategisk kompetensförsörjning vid Uppsala universitet” (UFV 2025/1446) (Review of strategic talent attraction at Uppsala University) has been written by Sven Stafström, professor emeritus at Linköping University and member of the University Board, on behalf of the Vice-Chancellor.
The task was to survey and analyse how the University’s career pathways are contributing to the goal of being a world-leading university in research and education. The review was carried out in part through document studies, and in part through interviews with representatives of the disciplinary domains, faculties and departments. The investigator also made comparisons with Swedish and international higher education institutions.
The report will be sent out for internal consultation in the autumn, 2026.